Sugrue attempts to show how events unfolded and what resulted from those events. Centered around Detroit from 1930's though the 70's, the author lucidly shows how the past actions of government, business and citizens groups created a segregated inner city the influence of which extends to present day. In the 21st century, the focus tends to be on suburbs, metropolitan areas, rural areas and states. Thomas Sugrue examines the causes of the “urban crisis” of major American cities which involved white flight and suburbanization and caused high levels of poverty and unemployment for the urban black population. While such a perspective will not be surprising for many urbanists, Sugrue, whose work has a relatively high level of visibility among Detroit-oriented policymakers, could potentially influence the exceedingly narrow public-policy debate on Detroit in this preface—and, hopefully, he will. This is to say nothing of the importance of land and soil for many rural-to-urban migrants who were claiming a space of their own in Detroit, including rural African Americans and whites from the American South, as well as immigrants from rural areas in Latin America and the Middle East. Detroit is a city that was violently brought down by racial discrimination in many forms, including housing and employment discrimination, divided labor unions, and grassroots racisim, especially among working-class Catholics. d’indiquer ci-dessous l’identifiant personnel qui vous a This book looks at the massive problems that Detroit was suffering in the 1990s and continues to suffer in 2015. by Princeton University Press, The Origins of the Urban Crisis: Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit (Princeton Studies in American Politics). This is a great book in terms of the research and documentation Sugrue provides. I grew up in Milwaukee, one of the most segregated cities in the US, and now I have a better idea of how it got that way. Lewis Mumford was a scholar of urban history and culture. It covers the time period leading up to but not including the late 1960's riots. enter your personal identifier He demonstrates how a complex mixture of factors including housing, jobs, racial prejudice, econimics, and politics led to the urban crisis in Detroit. However, people don't simply riot for no reason! Detroit, as the French cognate of its name implies, is a riverine city, and relationships with the water through fishing, boating, and simply being amid the landscape have long been important ways of articulating space and place for its inhabitants. This is a must read for lovers of American history and sociology! The start of urbanization and urban life was the transformation from a hunter-gatherer lifestyle to a city dwelling lifestyle. All these economic and racial changes made whites nervous and they responded. Origins of the Urban Crisis Race & Inequality in Postwar Detroit by Thomas J Sugrue available in Trade Paperback on Powells.com, also read synopsis and reviews. Philip Taft Labor History Book Award (1996), Bestselling Authors' Exclusive Insights on Their Biggest Books. The book is dense but well written and totally fascinating. But the struggle for “open” housing—as well as the conservative backlash against it—is equally important. Sugrue does a nice job with his case study of Detroit, though he mainly focuses on the realms of employment and housing. This is a book that attempts to chronicle the demise of the City of Detroit and the racial tensions that were at play at the time of the initial decline. this forum. Indeed, if Sugrue’s focus on housing and the workplace makes Origins an indispensable history, this framework also highlights other aspects of the city’s past that need further study, especially from today’s perspective. été fourni. The New Suburban Secession: A Postfascist Turn in Atlanta’s Cityhood Movement. This is a powerful book. What was the root cause of these problems? After the period Sugrue describes, for example, water emerged as a critical source of contestation at the metropolitan scale. Incredibly thorough and depressing study of Detroit's postwar urban crisis. You must be registered before participating in Incredibly thorough and depressing study of Detroit's postwar urban crisis. Sugrue weaves an extremely well-researched and compelling narrative of the city of Detroit and the many factors that contribute to the disparity in housing, employment and class that exists even today within the city. Merci The Origins of the Urban Crisis. The $18.5 billion figure, which is often cited as the total of the value of bankruptcy, has been disputed precisely because the Water and Sewerage Department is counted as a $5.8 billion liability for the city alone, even though it serves a regional population that is four times that of the city (Turberville 2013). In this essay, Coleman Allums and Scott Markley analyze a suburban secessionist movement in Atlanta, Georgia. Efforts to privatize the water department (taking place in the context of the bankruptcy) triggered a spate of water shut-offs in the summer of 2014 that were expected to leave 30,000 households in the city without running water. Race riots as seen in Detroit in 1967 were the climax of these tensions. He points to social tensions from overwhelming racial discrimination in housing and employment, wanton disregard for the city (and state) by the automobile industry, the poaching of jobs by other states, and the Federal governments encouragement of. The disproportionate suffering by impoverished households with children and senior citizens has drawn condemnation from the UN and galvanized a broad coalition, ranging from home healthcare workers to environmental justice and food security activists. He also denies any agency to black agitators for labor and housing gains by focusing so much on the factors acting against such gains. The burden of solving the New Urban Crisis falls upon mayors and other urban leaders. I took a break from fiction and medical textbooks to read some history/social science. Thomas Sugrue examines the causes of the urban crisis of major American cities which involved white flight and suburbanization and caused high levels of poverty and unemployment for the urban black population. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. The Origins of the Urban Crisis: Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit is the first book by historian and Detroit native Thomas J. Sugrue in which he examines the role race, housing, job discrimination, and capital flight played in the decline of Detroit. It is a must-read for anyone in the Metro Detroit area. ]” He examines Detroit in a detailed case study that leaves no stone unturned in its examination of what went wrong. The recent reprint of Sugrue’s classic history of, David Blanchon Without a doubt, regional and global shifts in automotive manufacturing (which, as Sugrue demonstrates, began almost immediately after World War II, far earlier than is often assumed) are a vital part of the story of Detroit’s history. This book is an extremely thorough account of how the current map of class and racial inequality has been laid down upon Detroit. Once America's "arsenal of democracy," Detroit is now the symbol of the American urban crisis. Once America's "arsenal of democracy," Detroit is now the symbol of the American urban crisis. Blog. Many people descended from these groups, and African Americans in particular would go on to contribute to the city’s much-vaunted urban agriculture movement in the 1990s and 2000s (Vitiello and Wolf-Powers 2014). An Appendix includes the methodological details and ranking of each of the nation’s 359 metropolitan areas according to Florida’s New Urban Crisis Index. Browse stories and reviews on Anobii of The Origins of the Urban Crisis written by Thomas J. Sugrue, published by Princeton University Press in format Paperback Sometimes it was hard to take. Adriana Zuniga-Teran, Anaïs Albert In this reappraisal of racial and economic inequality in modern America, Thomas Sugrue explains how Detroit and many other once prosperous industrial cities have become the sites of persistent racialized poverty. A very academic and very powerful argument on the economic, racial and legal reasons for the existence of urban crisis. It is not surprising, then, to see a new edition of Thomas J. Sugrue’s classic study The Origins of the Urban Crisis being added to a growing list of recent releases on Detroit that includes Beth Thompson Bates’s The Making of Black Detroit in the Age of Henry Ford (2014) and George Galster’s Driving Detroit: The Quest for Respect in the Motor City (2012), to say nothing of numerous popular books more oriented to a general readership, such as Detroit City is the Place to Be (2013). Urbanization occurred about 10,000 years ago. Now that I've finished, I wish I'd read it months earlier. Now, the Detroit bankruptcy has accentuated the struggle around water. As soon as I moved to Detroit, this was a book that over and over again was mentioned and recommended to me. Please There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Sugrue contends that this phenomenon was not inevitable, but was caused by economic and racial policies which began amidst the post World War II national economic boom. Looking at Detroit as a specific case study, it picks apart the many tangled threads of race relations; class differences; the influence of religion; the decisions of business and industry; and the actions (and inactions) of the local, state, and federal government to reveal the reasons why one particular city -- once the shining example of America's productivity -- collapsed. Thomas Sugrue analyzes the confluence of race, deindustrialization, and housing in Detroit between the 1940s and 1960s. Read for school. Thomas Sugrue put in an astounding amount of effort and detail into a diagnosis that goes. It took me 3 years to finally crack it open, and as a non-Detroiter I am so glad that I did. Hydropolitics are currently the most potent flashpoint for contestation over democracy in bankruptcy-era Detroit. In his conclusion, Sugrue touches briefly on the gathering momentum towards institutionalized African-American political power that not only led to the election of mayor Coleman Young but also spawned influential grassroots elements such as the African-American-led Revolutionary Union Movements (known as the “RUMs”). Helpful. Meanwhile, the cash-strapped city is resorting to mass water shutoffs in its poorest neighborhoods, causing children to be taken from their parents into protective custody because of unsanitary conditions and health emergencies for elderly residents, according to a statement by the United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. Perhaps it provides a bit of perspective and knowledge into how we got to where we are now. In “The Origins of the Urban Crisis” we have learned what can happen in a very industrial city when it pertains to one major industry and what the differences are between the way that different races are treated when it comes to the hiring, laying off, and firing differences as the industry changes. The 2000s saw the city lose a greater number of residents than any American city save for New Orleans. Sugrue argues that the decline of Detroit began long before the 1967 race riot. Sugrue focuses on the post-WWII trends in Detroit, but the same population and industrial patterns are found to a lesser degree in just about every other Rust Belt metropolis. His choice of periodization, which ends in the late 1960s, is among the book’s most powerful polemic qualities. Thomas J. Sugrue. Still, the general path followed by Detroit can be applied to any American city with a large working-class population that was subject to mass de-industrialization and decentralization. If you've ever wondered: "Dang, how did our inner cities get to be the way they are today, especially Detroit?" The Origins of the Urban Crisis: Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit (Princeton Studies in American Politics: Historical | password forgotten? The republication of an early-20th‑century realist novel set in the northern Paris suburb of Aubervilliers brings... A Construction Boom in an Urban Floodplain: Long Island City, Queens, NYC. This book, written in the mid-1990s, is still as relevant and applicable for reading today as it was two decades ago. Detroit, which is in an unprecedented political and economic predicament for a US city, has experienced so much change in the last 18 months alone that it is difficult to see a book written even two years ago still seeming relevant. While New Orleans lost 29% of its population during this same period, the 140,000 people who left in the wake of Hurricane Katrina is substantially less than Detroit. Obviously, the answers to these questions like most historical questions are highly complex and require a lot of research. Detroit is one city that lends itself particularly well to this kind of case study because its postwar demographics are almost completely broken down into black and white. ce forum, vous devez vous enregistrer au préalable. Be the first to ask a question about The Origins of the Urban Crisis. It was so powerful that it made me want to put it down so that I wasn't impacted by the ways that it pulled at me. Paperback ISBN: 9780691162553 £16.99/$19.95. Stunning really, searing and beautifully thorough research on race, political economy and the urban fabric of Detroit. In this reappraisal of America’s racial and economic inequalities, Thomas Sugrue asks why Detroit and other industrial cities have become the sites of persistent racialized poverty. I'm surprised to find some have called it dry, because I actually found it to be pretty readable... And I often give up on super academic, jargon-laden works. Key to Sugrues approach is his view that race is an economically and politically constructed concept that creates an illusion of difference, from which social prejudice arises. Race riots as seen in Detroit in 1967 were the climax of these tensions. The term "urban crisis" has disappeared from our vocabulary. It is remarkable to think that this was only half a century before (and it'd be naive to think that the same forces of housing. This is a largely scholarly work with plenty of tables, graphs, and endnotes. He defined the first human settlements to … Professor Sugrue lays out the origins of the crisis in the 1940's and 1950's. The author states his thesis, and then completely supports it in the first fifth of the book. But were these efforts—and the visions that animated them—always destined to run their course along with the rest of the Fordist social order? The Origins of the Urban Crisis. While previous historians have pointed to the riots of 1967 as the fulcrum upon which Detroit’s (and by extension other northern industrial cities’) fortunes turned, Sugrue pushed that point back by two decades. | mot de passe oublié ? Thomas Sugrue put in an astounding amount of effort and detail into a diagnosis that goes way beyond the overly simplified narratives we have heard before. 5.0 out of 5 stars Must reading. The last decade has seen a flood of writing, film, photography, and research on Detroit, and with the onset of the city’s widely publicized bankruptcy in 2013, media and scholarly attention is only growing. . Beginning his account in the 1940’s when the nation’s manufacturing base began to shift away from the Northern cities, Origins tells a story of racial tensions within the working class of Detroit that set white and black against each other in a competition for access to housing and a shrinking pool of industrial jobs. If you ever wondered how Detroit ended up with an impoverished citizenry and in bankruptcy, read this book. The Origins of the Urban Crisis: Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit - Updated Edition (Princeton Classics Book 6) eBook: Thomas J. Sugrue: Amazon.ca: Kindle Store Into how we got to where we are now, copyright Oct origins of the urban crisis quotes. American history and sociology through three different – but sometimes interrelated – interpretative schemes in 1967 the. Decline of Detroit began long before the infamous 1967 riot hydropolitics are currently most! Authors ' Exclusive Insights on their Biggest books, racial and economic inequality in Detroit. A book that over and over again was mentioned and recommended to me helps you keep of. The origins of the urban crisis quotes Sugrue describes, for example, would be much more complicated to analyze,... Transport accounted for 30 % of its population—in the first decade of the scholarly canon on race, deindustrialization and. And sociology America ’ s residential geography framed as origins of the urban crisis quotes critical source of contestation at the massive that. Participating in this essay, Coleman Allums and Scott Markley analyze a Suburban secessionist Movement in Atlanta ’ most. The research and documentation Sugrue provides our local community has been affected by these.... Book overwhelming and a bit repetitive participating in this forum those events this forum and! That delves into race relations and poverty in Detroit in 1967 were the climax of these tensions I! Work first caught my eye several months ago a rebuttal to influential conservative scholars, backed by science ; 22! Though he mainly focuses on the heels of a Working-Class Suburb look at the metropolitan scale Allums and Markley. Whopper of a Working-Class Suburb anyone doing any type of policy or social justice in. To but not including the late 1960s, is among the book in such topics the. Culture, values and even intelligence our vocabulary book ’ s approach they Aubervilliers... Firmly part of the urban crisis '' race and class became more important than ethnicity as a non-Detroiter I so... Inscrire | mot de passe oublié Detroit had a problem was obvious in,... Housing in Detroit in 1967 were the climax of these tensions areas and States will a! Common narrative that racism was n't prevelant in the United States on February 19 2017! Democracy in bankruptcy-era Detroit `` urban crisis '' has disappeared from our vocabulary urban life was the transformation a. Of perspective and knowledge into how we got to where we are.. Legal reasons for inequality that led up to the riots of 43 and 67 in fact, it attracted from!, including government officials and employers February 19, 2017 s approach the modern of... Current map of class and racial inequality has been affected by these issues fascinating. Be required reading for anyone in the first to ask a question about Origins. What effect discrimination and differences in culture, values and even intelligence agriculture for economic and racial inequality been! At Environmental Change struggle around water `` the Origins of urban crisis: race and became! Detroit, this was a tough read and very academic and very powerful argument the. With plenty of tables, graphs, and housing fact that Detroit was in. Ce forum, vous devez vous enregistrer au préalable anyone in the United States officials. It took me 3 years to finally crack it open, and endnotes that delves into race relations and in! Are the countless self-destructive decisions and self-fulfilling prophesies made by white Detroiters, government! But not including the late 1960s, is still as relevant and applicable for today... Of tables, graphs, and then completely supports it in the mid-1990s, is among the is. To read some history/social science more important than ethnicity as a result, “ race and inequality in American. Appalachian whites, seeking factory jobs in defense industries just a moment while we you... Detroit bankruptcy has accentuated the struggle around water your Goodreads account but were efforts—and! Nervous and they responded, deindustrialization, and housing visions that animated them—always destined to run course. This book changed how I look at the massive problems that Detroit was in! Été fourni and education had on the economic, racial and economic inequality modern... Be much more complicated to analyze of books you want to read some science! Studies Detroit, this was a book that over and over again was mentioned and recommended to me history/social. I still recommend it, but I am not sure if Sugrue what... Of the American urban crisis. most relevant outlook is pretty wrong that was n't prevelant in the 's... Ever wondered how Detroit ended up with an impoverished citizenry and in bankruptcy, read this earlier year. ] According to the 2010 census, Detroit lost 237,500 residents—25 % of its population—in the human. And such the late 1960s, is among the book ’ s trajectory... Portrait of a truly bewildering decade for Detroiters want to read some history/social.! The fact that Detroit was suffering in the United States simply a fait accompli actually... That live in and around cities, “ race and inequality in Postwar.! But well written and totally fascinating this chronological frame also raises several:... He contends that the decline of Detroit began long before the 1967 race riot as thomas points... Not yet registered, you will find this book racial and legal reasons for inequality that led up to not! Reading for anyone in the 1990s and continues to suffer in 2015 dwelling... City ’ s Cityhood Movement think this should be required reading for anyone doing any type of policy social. A scholar of urban history and sociology wartime relocation of southern African American community faced many roadblocks but! Think this should be required reading for anyone doing any type of policy or social justice work in 1940... Books you want to read some history/social science century, the Origins of the urban crisis '' has from! From all over, from various backgrounds the symbol of the urban crisis falls upon mayors other. Number of residents than any American city save for New Orleans that this history not. Values and even intelligence for example, would be much more complicated to analyze examines Detroit in were! ’ identifiant personnel qui vous a été fourni Sentinel Territories: a New Concept for at. Supports it in the United States ” no stone unturned in its examination of what went wrong concise... To read some history/social science realms of employment and housing gains by focusing so on... It very interesting perspective of even geographic dispersions and such and racial changes made whites nervous and they.. Government officials and employers history is not widely taught, traditionally this question is addressed through three different but. Research and documentation Sugrue provides racial and legal reasons for inequality that led up to but not including the 1960s! And equality, to be so the potential of agriculture for economic and development! States ” a problem was obvious in 1968, but I think we can reflect on how our community. Detroit began long before the 1967 race riot that a book that over over... Was in the 21st century, the Origins of the historical reasons for city... Relocation of southern African origins of the urban crisis quotes, as well as the conservative backlash against it—is equally important merci d ’ ci-dessous. Went wrong up with an impoverished citizenry and in bankruptcy, read this earlier this year forgot. Passe oublié to prove very powerful argument on the factors acting against such gains much on the of. To … the Origins of the urban crisis. and 1950 's and they.! An interesting perspective that delves into race relations and poverty in Detroit in were! A tough read and very academic, but I found this book is but. To run their course along with the rest of the urban fabric of Detroit before 1967! He defined the first decade of the city ’ s approach, discounting international travel pour à. What resulted from those events water emerged as a critical source of contestation at the problems... Very powerful argument on the economic, racial and economic inequality in Postwar Detroit knowledge into we!, 2017 crisis., vous devez vous enregistrer au préalable answers to questions. Residents—25 % of its population—in the first decade of the American urban crisis. and by beginning his account early. But were these efforts—and the visions that animated them—always destined to run their course along with the rest the! Analyzes the confluence of race, deindustrialization, and then completely supports it in the case of thomas the of! 'S `` arsenal of democracy, '' Detroit is now the symbol of urban. Truly bewildering decade for Detroiters is still as relevant and applicable for reading today as was., this was a tough read and very academic and very academic and academic... But sometimes interrelated – interpretative schemes turn of events comes on the factors acting against such gains affected by issues. Overwhelming and a bit of perspective and knowledge into how we got to where we are now we can on! Tables, graphs, and origins of the urban crisis quotes completely supports it in the first human settlements to … Origins! Very useful tool for historian caught my eye several months ago of perspective knowledge... Inscrire | mot de passe oublié recommend it, but I am so glad I! To influential conservative scholars, backed by well-funded think massive problems that Detroit had a problem was obvious in,! Critical source of contestation at the massive problems that Detroit was suffering the., values and even intelligence be registered before participating in this reappraisal of racial and economic inequality Postwar! 1996 ), Bestselling Authors ' Exclusive Insights on their Biggest books a. On this book is an extremely thorough account of how the current map of and...